Should you bid? Bid / no-bid scorecard
Score a federal opportunity across the seven factors that actually decide wins — and get a disciplined, defensible pursue-or-pass recommendation instead of a gut call.
Do you know this buyer, their mission and hot buttons? Have you shaped the requirement?
Can you clearly meet the requirement with relevant, recent, similar past performance?
Do you know who else will bid, and is there a credible reason you’d be preferred (incumbency, discriminators)?
Can your fully-burdened pricing realistically win without bidding below cost?
Do you have the people and time to write a strong proposal AND staff the work if you win?
Are Section L/M and the requirements clear, realistic, and within reach for you?
Does winning open a new customer, vehicle or market that matters to your growth?
This is a disciplined decision aid — a weighted fit score, not a statistical win probability. The weights are sensible defaults; your team should adjust them to your own win themes and risk tolerance. Use it to make the pursue-or-pass call consistent and defensible, not to replace capture judgment.
Why a bid/no-bid gate wins more (by chasing less)
Writing a federal proposal costs real money — senior people, nights and weekends, and the opportunity cost of everything else they could be doing. The teams that win consistently don’t bid more; they bid better, putting their best effort behind the opportunities where they have a genuine edge and walking away from the rest.
A structured scorecard makes that discipline repeatable. Instead of “this feels winnable,” you get a consistent rubric every opportunity passes through — so your pursue-or-pass calls are defensible to leadership and your B&P budget goes where it counts.
Decided to bid? Here’s the next move
If the score says go, make the pricing competitive with the wrap rate calculator, and confirm you can bid in the right lane with the set-aside eligibility checker. Then GovCon helps you build a compliant, Section L/M-aligned proposal and manage the pursuit through your pipeline — so a “bid” decision turns into a submitted, winning response.
Frequently asked questions
What is a bid/no-bid decision?+
It’s the disciplined call every contractor should make before investing in a proposal: is this opportunity worth pursuing, given our fit, the competition, the price to win, and the resources it will take? Federal proposals are expensive to write, so a structured bid/no-bid gate protects your team from chasing work you’re unlikely to win.
How does the score work?+
You rate the opportunity 1–5 on seven weighted factors — customer knowledge, solution fit, competitive position, price, resources, compliance and strategic value. Each rating is scaled by its weight and combined into a 0–100 bid-fit score, with a recommendation band and a callout of your weakest factors so you know exactly what to shore up.
Is this a real "Pwin" (probability of win)?+
No — and we’re careful to say so. A true Pwin is a statistical estimate built from your historical win data. This is a structured fit score: a consistent, defensible way to compare opportunities and make the pursue-or-pass call. Treat the number as a decision aid, not a forecast.
Can I change the weights?+
The defaults reflect common capture practice — customer relationship and solution fit carry the most weight because they move win rates the most. Your organization should tune them to your own win themes and risk tolerance; the value is in applying the same rubric to every opportunity.
When should I no-bid?+
When the cost and risk of bidding outweigh a realistic chance of winning — typically a low score driven by weak customer knowledge, poor solution fit, or no credible path on price. A confident no-bid is a win: it frees your B&P budget and your best people for opportunities you can actually take.
Find, score & win it in one place
GovCon ties these tools together with opportunity matching, AI proposal drafting, a capture pipeline and a reusable library — free to start, no credit card.
No card · cancel anytime